Was jail guard’s death an ‘off-duty event’?
The story filed Sept. 16 on the Channel 8 Web site was brief: “A Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department corrections officer died Thursday night after crashing into a truck in downtown Las Vegas.
“Victor Hunter may have suffered a heart attack before crashing into the back of a pickup truck at Main Street and Bonneville Avenue. Hunter was taken to University Medical Center where he died.
“The driver of the truck was not hurt. Hunter worked as a corrections officer at the Clark County Detention Center.”
End of story? See what you think.
Victor Hunter had made the news once before, when he and his son Christopher graduated — the only father-son team ever to so graduate — from the Metro Police Academy together in February, 2008. The story actually mentioned that the father, Victor, was slimmer and more physically fit than his son, so the dad helped the son with the physical training while Christopher helped his dad with the academics. “I had to drag him along most of the time,” Victor said, laughing. “But it was a great team effort.”
Corrections officers at the downtown jail usually work 12-hour shifts, but it appears Victor was assigned to a shorter, eight-hour shift, from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., on the Thursday night he died. That’s why he didn’t drive to work with his son, as was their usual practice.
Victor should have still been at work when he died, at about 11:37 p.m., only a block-and-a-half from the jail. Why wasn’t he?
Piecing together accounts from his widow, Noreta Hunter, and other Metro officers including a first-hand witness, a call went down at the jail between 10 and 11 that Thursday evening to haul some cots to an upper floor to handle an inmate overflow.
Victor Hunter was assisting his partner, a female officer, to lift and hand over a folding cot, when he dropped the cot and ran off, saying, “I don’t feel too good, I gotta use the rest room.”
Officer Hunter could then be heard vomiting in the rest room, “I mean very loud,” a witness tells me. “He was throwing up a lot; it was clear, it was yellowish …”
They subsequently sat him down. Victor Hunter said “I don’t feel good. I feel really sick.”
“He’s bending over, holding his upper stomach, his lower chest. He says ‘My chest hurts’ and he feels like it’s a heart attack,” said the witness, who asked that his name not be used. His supervisor, Sgt. Shawn Judd, was sent for, and arrived some minutes later accompanied by an infirmary nurse named “Pat.”
“So Nurse Pat is standing right next to me, so I figure being trained medical personnel she knows the symptom and what not, I’m rubbing his back, saying ‘You’re gonna be OK, Victor, things are gonna be all right.’
“As the sergeant arrived I left them in his hands, I went back to my unit, I told Chris, ‘You should look to your dad, he’s not all right.’ … But he was too busy, he couldn’t go to his dad. … An hour later we get the notice he’s been in a car accident, they sent him home and he’s dead. …
“Officer Wang or Officer Garvey might have seen her (the nurse) give him a shot; I know she was fired the next day. They pretty much told everybody it was gonna be considered a line-of-duty death, they were just waiting for the sheriff to confirm it, but then that changed. …
“I know he was real sick, Christopher couldn’t go see him because he was real busy. Imagine that, he gets told ‘Go talk to your dad,’ and an hour later he’s told (his dad) is dead. So he was beating himself up, but I told him not to do that, I mean, he was real busy.”
The widow, Noreta Hunter, tells me Victor called her on his cell phone from the car as he tried to drive home, saying he felt extremely sick and that the nurse had given him a shot and told him to drive home.
When he stopped talking and the phone went dead, she called her son and urge him to duplicate the route Victor usually drove home. Son Christopher didn’t return my calls, but other officers say when he drove the route, he saw the flashing lights of the accident scene, only a short distance from the jail. It appears Noreta had heard Victor’s final words.
“Of course the nurse did wrong,” she says. “The nurse gave him a shot and they fired the nurse they next day. They should have called 9-1-1. The first thing the sergeant said when he talked to me was he was pointing to his chest. Why would they send their employee to the infirmary? I’m not saying we’re better than the prisoners, but why would they send him to the infirmary where they treat the prisoners and not dial 9-1-11, not call an ambulance?”
The Hunter family’s problems were only beginning. First they were told Victor’s was an on-duty death. Then the Metropolitan Police Department, which self-insures for workers’ compensation coverage, changed its mind.
Although it appears in the end eight motorcycle patrolmen volunteered to provide an escort, other officers say the family was denied any official police funeral — common even when an on-duty officer dies in a single-vehicle crash. The local Police Employee Assistance Program promised $1,000, but that hasn’t yet shown up and would pay less than half the cost of the casket, anyway. The family’s electricity was turned off — Victor always paid the bill. The tow company is demanding a large sum for towing and storing Victor’s car after he died at the wheel.
“The undersheriff sat down at the funeral service and told us he was gonna see us as soon as Victor was buried in California, but he hasn’t. It’s just been one lie after another. They suggested a mortuary to us; the mortuary embalmed him without my signing anything, so we couldn’t even get a second autopsy of him.”
Under the 1976 federal Public Safety Officers’ Benefits Program (www.ojp.usdoj.gov/BJA/grant/psob/psob_death.html) a death that occurs within 24 hours of an unusually strenuous or stressful event on the job is considered an on-duty death, qualifying for benefits.
But “If you sign out sick and go home, even the federal statute won’t cover you unless there was some activity at work that contributed to or caused that heart attack,” local police union chief Chris Collins tells me. “To me the key piece of evidence is the video.” Virtually every inch of the jail is under video surveillance. “If he had some medical issues it’d be on videotape. If it shows he did indeed have some medical episode at work,” that could qualify a death an hour or two later as “on-duty,” Mr. Collins says.
But Noreta Hunter was reportedly told by a Metro sergeant she’d better not run up any new big bills when she required medical care after Victor’s death, since “When Victor died, so did your health benefits.”
Did “Nurse Pat” give Victor a shot of Phenergan, a medicine for allergic reactions, and send him home, as reported, without calling an ambulance for a man who exhibited all the symptoms of and even said he feared he was having a heart attack? Was she fired the next day, as reported, and if so why?
Brad Cain, counsel at the Naphcare corporate offices in Birmingham, Ala., said his staff wouldn’t normally treat a jail employee, except to stabilize an emergency condition until the employee could be transported. He wouldn’t discuss Victor Hunter’s condition or treatment that night.
Metro spokesman Bill Cassell returned my call, leaving a voice message as follows: “That was an off-duty event so we wouldn’t have any information on that that’s releasable. I also wonder what you’re looking at and why. I would hope that we can allow this gentleman and his family to rest in peace.”
Lawyers aren’t always our favorite people, these days. But I kind of hope something else. I kind of hope Noreta Hunter finds a good attorney.
October 30th, 2011 at 1:45 pm
To my fellow bloggers and Corrections Officer Hunter’s family;
Baring any other additional information that would change the circumstances of what I have just read, In my opinion this again is yet another example of the way the Police Department treats their employees. This is outrageous and screams corruption, why can’t the company do what is right, give the proper benefits that was originally agreed upon and not have to cause the family to contact an attorney and go to litigation which in turn hits the taxpayer with an even larger settlement in the end. But wait, maybe there is another way, how about stealing money and property from the police union, get as much dirt as you can on the police administration and then be guaranteed a medical retirement and no criminal prosecution, or in other words do a (Uncle Fester). I currently am going through a similar situation, I have two denied w/c claims for almost a year that I am fighting along with my attorney Gabriel Martinez esq. (hint). I complained of chest, back, and jaw pain at work (twice), eventually had heart surgery and they still won’t accept my w/c claim, they are probably waiting and hoping for me to drop dead, then it is easier for them to play their lawyer games. Don’t rely on the police union they are useless and they are not on your side. Stay the course, trust nobody, especially the police department, you will prevail. God Bless you, and RIP Victor. Just an old cop reflecting,
Gordon Martines
email: [email protected] (if you would like to contact me)
October 31st, 2011 at 10:59 am
My heart genuinely goes out to the Hunter family, but let this story be a lesson to anyone who aspires to waste their life as a uniformed stooge for the State: your life isn’t worth any more to the Powers That Be than those of the mere mundanes over whom you think you’re superior. You’re an expendable tool, just like the bullets in the service weapon you’ll carry.
Victor, was slimmer and more physically fit than his son, so the dad helped the son with the physical training while Christopher helped his dad with the academics.
“Academics?” I can only imagine what THAT consists of at a typical porkademy.